Held firm, held humbly
Conviction and humility together
Watch a man six months past his great reorientation, and you may flinch a little. He has recovered real convictions, hard-won and true, and he has become almost impossible to sit beside. Every conversation is a correction waiting to happen; every disagreement is a contest he intends to win; the searching humility that marked him in the wilderness has hardened, somewhere along the way, into a certainty that bristles. He has not stopped being right about much. He has simply traded one rigidity for another and called the swap maturity. This is the characteristic temptation at the close of finding new bearings: to grip the recovered truth so tightly and so proudly that the rebuilt faith turns as brittle and graceless as the thing it replaced. The apostle prays the cure directly, asking that love would keep growing alongside knowledge and real discernment, the two rising together rather than one crowding out the other, and reminding us that the LORD's servant is not built for quarreling but for gentleness, patience, the readiness to teach without wounding. The bearings worth having are held two ways at once, firmly and humbly, sure of the truth and tender with the people still feeling for it in the dark.
“This I pray, that your love may abound yet more and more in knowledge and all discernment.”
— Paul, to the Philippians — Philippians 1:9 (WEB)
“The Lord's servant must not quarrel, but be gentle towards all, able to teach, patient.”
Here is the trap waiting at the very end of reorientation, after the hard work is mostly done: having finally reached firm ground, you can plant your feet and turn combative, swapping your old uncertainty for a new arrogance that is every bit as ugly and a good deal louder. The recovered convictions are real, and you are right to hold them. The question is how. Hold them firmly, yes, with the settledness of someone who has tested the floor and knows it holds. But hold them humbly too, with love still growing alongside your knowledge, gentle and patient with people who are exactly where you used to be, fumbling in a fog you remember. Remember that you see truly now and still only in part; certainty about the cornerstone is not omniscience about everything. The mark of a mature new bearing is never how hard you can argue it or how fast you can correct a stranger. It is how graciously you can hold something you are genuinely sure of, without needing to break anyone over it.